Top 5 Best Eyebrow Pencils For Natural Effect

Back with my article Top 5 Best Eyebrow Pencils, the latter being essential when creating your makeup. Indeed, I cannot repeat it enough, well-defined eyebrows provide structure and a certain cohesion. In short, they allow a look or a face to be totally changed and make it more harmonious. If I have already written an article on the best technique for plucking your eyebrows, with a very precise comparison, I am now tackling the best eyebrow pencils on the market. I deliberately chose pencils, which in my opinion are the easiest way to structure your brows. I also like powders, I will tell you about them soon.

How to choose your eyebrow pencil?

The fineness of the tip
Perfect color
Outfit
Texture
Amount of product
Presence of a bottle brush

With all of these items, you’ll be virtually sure to find the best eyebrow pencil ever! To summarize, the fineness of the pencil allows an ultra-precise line, therefore, a natural result. The color, for its part, is essential … Indeed, it is a question of choosing a shade with cold undertones for chestnuts or blondes (taupe shade), warm tones for red hair, red, plum (orange hues) & dark brown see black for very dark hair. Of course, you will have to be careful not to choose a shade that is too pronounced, indeed, it can force the features of your face and make your gaze very strict. The texture & the hold come together … You will need a material that is neither too oily nor too dry in order to obtain perfectly defined eyebrows, which will not migrate during the day.

The hold is most important on dry textured eyebrow pencils. Finally, it should be noted that the quantity of the eyebrow pencil is to be taken into account, too many products finish quickly, I will note the grams lower for you, you should not be disappointed. Most pencils have a brush to style the eyebrows at the start and end of the makeup. It is clearly essential and very practical when integrated into the product. Styling, therefore, allows you to place the hair well but also to blur the excess material if your hand is too heavy.

Our Selection 5 Best Eyebrow Pencils

Precisely My Brow Pencil

Definitely my favorite eyebrow pencil! The ultra-fine mine allows you to trace your eyebrows to perfection, moreover, shade number 3 suits me perfectly and does not contain any orange undertones. Once you have found your favorite shade, you can choose your product from the entire Benefit brow range. No need to struggle to re-test the colors, they are identical, all products combined. The texture of the mine is perfect, neither too dry nor too oily, and allows you to easily draw your eyebrows, without forcing too much. It is therefore one of the best eyebrow pencils, for many beauty addicts. The hold is excellent and the resulting natural, with a hair-to-hair effect.

In short :

Fine mine
Perfect texture
Ergonomic
Ultra-simple layout
Bottlebrush
Large choice of shades
0.08 gram
Available in 12 shades

Kat Von D Signature Brow

This Kat Von D product had to be included in this article on the best eyebrow pencils. It is by far the most precise and fine mine that I have been able to test. If the texture is drier than normal, you can draw your lines by insisting on bursts. Indeed, it is not a question of forcing on the mine, you will risk breaking it, which already happened to me at the beginning of my test. You have to go gradually without pressing too much, you will see the result is downright stunning. Due to its dry texture, the hold is optimal, I had nothing to complain about on that side. Finally, the Light Brown shade matches very well with my eyebrow shade, with no orange undertones.

High precision, ultra-fine lead
1mm x 1.5mm Elliptical Tip
Dry texture
Vegan
Ultra natural rendering
0.065 gram
Available in 8 shades

Anastasia Beverly Hills Perfect Brow Pencil

A true eyebrow star, the Anastasia Beverly Hills brand has made itself known thanks to its products with incomparable rendering. I have also included 2 different products in this Top 5 of the best eyebrow pencils. I’ve always been a die-hard fan of the duo powder from the same brand, I’ve used it for years, and only this last one. In view of the overall quality of the brand, I wanted to test other formats.

This pencil has the advantage of having a large quantity of product, in fact, like a real pencil, the lead is more imposing. It’s up to you to cut it as you wish. If I had any doubts about the accuracy of this pencil, I was pleasantly surprised. The texture is perfect and allows for a nice line without too much effect. The material works extremely well, without overflowing. Finally, the taupe or the blonde suit me, the rendering is once again natural.

Real sharpening pencil
Smooth & precise line
Vitamin E, aloe vera, chamomile, and calendula
Long-lasting
Natural effect
Larger quantity
0.095 gram
Available in 7 shades

Urban Decay Brow Beater

It’s been ages since I’ve talked about an Urban Decay product as if the brand has disappeared from our makeup bags. It was while looking for one of the best eyebrow pencils that I came across the Brow Beater. With unanimous ratings and a significant amount of opinion, I got started. The texture of the product is perfect, it allows you to get a nice line without being a pro.

Indeed, this eyebrow pencil is ideal for beginners of its beveled lead & its ease of application. You are unlikely to miss it, this is also the case with the previous pencils, however, this one is still more manageable. Moreover, it blends perfectly and leaves a natural result. Finally, be careful to choose your shade, if you hesitate between 2 shades, always choose the lightest shade. This will prevent you from unpleasant surprises and a result that is too marked.

Beveled mine
Uniform & natural rendering
Waterproof
Low amount of product
Vegan
0.05 gram
Available in 7 shades

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

The second ABH product of this article of the best eyebrow pencils, and for good reason, this version is not in the form of a sharpening pencil like the previous one. Here is its Brow wiz version which features an ultra-fine retractable lead. The product has a material that is always perfect, dry enough for optimal hold & greasy enough for a slippery line, as it should be. However, be careful not to press too hard on the lead. This is the eyebrow pencil with the most choice of shades, and we love it! While I don’t have too many problems finding my perfect shade, I know that not everyone is. Finally, easy to blend, it allows you to adjust the desired result, to obtain your perfect eyebrows.

Mechanical retractable mine
Ultrafine mine
Vitamin E and vegetable oils
Natural result
Long-lasting
A good amount of product
0.085 gram
Available in 10 shades

Best cheap eyebrow pencils

I couldn’t finish this Top 5 Best Eyebrow Pencils article without slipping in some cheap product. Indeed, if the previous pencils are clearly the best on the market, there are still some eyebrow pencils which are worth the detour and which are around 10 €. You need something for all budgets, so here is my selection …

Sephora Retractable Eyebrow Pencil

The most successful eyebrow pencil from Sephora. It strongly resembles its more expensive competitors but has very few colors, we note this shortcoming. In addition, with its retractable lead and its slightly oilier texture than the best eyebrow pencils presented above, it can do the trick for beauty addicts on a tight budget. The quantity of product rivals its competitors, but the hold is less important. Level mine, no complaints, it is fine and rather easy to handle. This Sephora eyebrow pencil remains a good alternative!

Fine mine
Rather oily texture
Correct but not flawless outfit
Nice quantity of product
0.08 gram
Available in 5 shades

Zoeva Graphic Brows

Latest of the best cheap eyebrow pencils, here is the Zoeva branded version. Being a follower of pretty accessible brands, I was tempted by this test. Very well rated by consumers, the pencil is precise & long-lasting. Indeed, its rather well-made mine allows drawing its eyebrows correctly quickly. Beware of the stability of the mine which can be compromised, in fact, it will be necessary to be cautious and not to insist too much. It should be noted all the same that it is the eyebrow pencil that has the fewest shades available. This may not necessarily be suitable for everyone. You will have to be extra careful if you choose this eyebrow pencil. It is still a good value for money.